UIL Speech Judges

Rounds judged: 25
Approach: Communication skills and resolution of substantive issues are of equal importance
Philosophy:
Debate in the style that works best for you! I'm more interested in engaging with your unique approach rather than imposing any set norms. Please be polite and respectful to others during the round. Speed: I’m comfortable with any pace, as long as your delivery is clear and understandable. Please check with your opponent before the round to get their preference. Voters: Please summarize key points and provide clear voters throughout the round. Strong voters should show a deep, conceptual grasp and comparison of arguments made by both sides. Organization: Please provide clear transitions and signposts in your constructive speech so that it is evident to others where different parts of your case begin and end. I value an overview or roadmap before rebuttals and signpost during to let others know where you want arguments applied on the flow. This not only promotes clarity but also ensures your opponent can flow and respond to your arguments. Organization makes for a more effective speaker. Traditional vs. Progressive: I’m open to both traditional and progressive styles. I evaluate rounds based on the strength of the arguments, analysis, and evidence presented. As long as the argument is well-conceptualized and defended, I’m on board. I prioritize your ability to pinpoint and effectively engage with the key arguments in the round, rather than attempting to address every point on the flow. I understand that time is limited, so make sure to use it efficiently.

Region of residence:
2

I will travel to: 2 6