Any Given Saturday: Judging Comments Critical for Educational Growth
By Ronnie, Rios, TMAA Marching Band Vice President | Thursday, September 30, 2010 12:57 PM
Think about loading up the car with the family, picking up grandma on the way to the stadium, snacking on homemade cookies, all while spending a beautiful day at your local marching band contest. Unfortunately, on any given Saturday, this picture could become tainted for marching bands and spectators alike if the adjudication process is flawed.
The judge’s decisions and comments absolutely do matter and they are the sole reason we are selected to serve as adjudicators. It is our responsibility to provide a positive commentary full of beneficial suggestions and musical growth opportunities for each performing group. Reward achievement like there is no tomorrow. We must always remember that our comments are a primary source for educational growth. The students, directors and parents deserve our best effort, and it is essential for the evolution of the activity.
The fact remains — there are many different styles of sound and movement. We must leave our favorite style and personal preferences at the press box door. Our goal for each and every band is to give the most exact educational comments possible for the styles presented. Look and listen for uniformity of movement and sound and reward it. Yes, our opinions are incredibly valuable, and constructive criticism should be our forte. But remember, months and months of hard work rest on every word we share. Make your words make their day.
Always be sure to react to the performance in real time. Not by band reputation or because the group is a name brand organization. Have a great judging season and keep your environment full of learning. Below are some ‘friendly’ reminders from the TMAA website.
• Adjudicators shall know and uphold all rules for music competition in the current issue of the Constitution and Contest Rules published by the University Interscholastic League.
• Adjudicators shall be physically, emotionally and mentally fit to discharge their duties at music contests.
• Adjudicators shall maintain an ethical code of conduct which will not impair or prejudice effectiveness as a judge, before, during and immediately following the competing dates.
• Adjudicators will honor all contracts, assignments and duties as prescribed by the contest chairman. Prompt notification of the contest chairman regarding emergency situations is required.
• Adjudicators shall avoid fraternizing with competing directors, administrators, or school officials prior to or during the contest.
• Adjudicators shall not discuss other adjudicators with directors or school officials. Criticism of other adjudicators will be made in writing to the Director of Music Activities, University Interscholastic League.